An independent mystery shopper team has exposed Australia’s gold buying scam revealing a massive $1,202 variance between the same parcels of gold given to each outlet and an extraordinary $4,915 variance for the same gold and diamond ring.
The greatest scams were exposed in Queensland (QLD), Western Australia (WA) and South Australia (SA) with mystery shoppers inspecting gold buyers across the country, including Cash Converters, The Gold Buyers, The Gold Company and various independent jewellery buyers.*
These covert visits by mystery shoppers from Retail Services 2000 revealed a lack of knowledge amongst gold buyers and a disparity about gold valuing methods. Further, the majority of outlets refused to give information regarding the day’s gold price, said they did not know the price that day or in one instance, stated that the exchange did not pay the price of gold stated on the gold market.
Each gold buying outlet was given exactly the same parcel of gold to value to ensure a level playing field. The non-descript parcel of gold items included a 9 carat yellow gold bracelet, necklace and two yellow gold wedding rings as well as an 18 carat bracelet, a yellow gold engagement ring without a stone and an 18 carat yellow gold engagement ring with three diamonds.
Pawn brokers quoted the lowest amount for gold jewellery and off the street outlets come out on top, the study revealed. Cash King Pawnbrokers of Queensland quoted ($698) while The Gold Company (headquartered in Sydney but offering a national service) offered the highest price of $1,900 for the parcel of gold jewellery. OM Jewellers ($1,705) in WA was the other top scorer in the country. Joining Cash King Brokers at the bottom of the rung were Cash Converters ($700) and Cash City ($700) in West Australia (full results table below).
When valuing an 18 carat yellow gold engagement ring with three diamonds, Retail Services 2000’s mystery shoppers found a huge discrepancy in quotes between the buyers. The chain of shops found in many Australian shopping centres, Gold Buyers, showed great variance between prices offered. As an example, the Gold Buyers in WA, QLD and VIC all gave a price of $85. The Gold Company offered a provisional price of $5,000 for the same diamond ring, stating a proper price could only be given by removing the diamonds.
Roy Cohen industry watchdog and expert valuer from The Gold Company says the growing prevalence of gold buying shops in NSW, VIC, QLD, SA and WA coincides with the rise in gold price over the past five years.
“The mystery shopper exercise really highlights the need to shop around if you’re selling unwanted gold, especially those selling gold with stones. It is important not to accept the price they get from the first gold buyer they see and it is crucial to approach experts in valuation if you want to receive a fair and equitable price for your jewellery.”









